SHROOMS GAME RECIPE · NOVEMBER 2, 2026
Schedule 1 shrooms recipe
These are fictional inventory items and saved calculator outputs for Schedule 1. The control is strongest by value after ingredient expense among the tested lists of at most four additions. It is not a universal game optimum or a measured sale. The new question here is how to rebuild the recipe when a material is excluded, rather than treating deletion as the only possible response.
A missing item changes the eligible recipes
We enumerate 1 + 16 + 16² + 16³ + 16⁴ = 69,905 ordered lists on the Shrooms base. The empty list and shorter recipes are included; repeats are allowed. Each list is recomputed from the base under the same saved standard rules. Seeded Mixing is off, quantity is one, and no production expense or selling deduction has been supplied.
For a one-item exclusion, every recipe containing that item is removed from consideration. That leaves 1 + 15 + 15² + 15³ + 15⁴ = 54,241 eligible inputs. We rank them by calculated value minus ingredient expense, with lower expense breaking ties. Alphabetical input order is the last tie-breaker. We do not assign a probability of a shortage or assume any actual shop stock.
| Excluded game item | Replacement ordered additions | Value | Expense | Remainder | Loss from $171 |
| Cuke | Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine → Viagor | $185 | $23 | $162 | $9 |
| Flu Medicine | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Gasoline | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Donut | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Energy Drink | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Mouth Wash | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Motor Oil | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Banana | Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean → Viagor | $189 | $22 | $167 | $4 |
| Chili | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Iodine | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Paracetamol | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Viagor | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Horse Semen | Gasoline → Cuke → Battery → Mega Bean | $189 | $22 | $167 | $4 |
| Mega Bean | Cuke → Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine | $187 | $21 | $166 | $5 |
| Addy | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
| Battery | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $191 | $20 | $171 | $0 |
Excluding an item that the selected leader never uses leaves that leader eligible. Twelve of the sixteen individual exclusions therefore retain the $171 remainder. The four ingredients actually present in the control each produce a lower best available remainder when excluded: Banana loses $4, Cuke loses $9, Horse Semen loses $4 and Mega Bean loses $5. Those are differences between optimized lists under specific constraints, not prices assigned to the missing items.
Deleting Horse Semen throws away more than necessary
Simply removing Horse Semen leaves Banana → Cuke → Mega Bean. The model recomputes this remaining order; it does not subtract an effect by hand. The table contrasts that deletion with a complete reoptimization over all eligible lists. It applies the same test to each ingredient in the control.
| Excluded item | Delete-only input | Delete-only remainder | Reoptimized input | Reoptimized remainder | Recovered remainder |
| Banana | Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $141 | Cuke → Horse Semen → Mega Bean → Viagor | $167 | $26 |
| Cuke | Banana → Horse Semen → Mega Bean | $113 | Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine → Viagor | $162 | $49 |
| Horse Semen | Banana → Cuke → Mega Bean | $128 | Gasoline → Cuke → Battery → Mega Bean | $167 | $39 |
| Mega Bean | Banana → Cuke → Horse Semen | $133 | Cuke → Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine | $166 | $33 |
The recovered column is reoptimized remainder minus delete-only remainder. Both candidates obey the same exclusion, but the replacement can change the other materials and their order. That freedom is the point of this test. A cheaper shortened list can lose more calculated value than it saves in ingredients; a slightly more expensive replacement can restore much of that loss.
For the Horse Semen exclusion, the replacement's final effects are Zombifying, Bright-Eyed, Cyclopean and Foggy. The control has Electrifying and Long Faced instead of the first two. A near-equal remainder does not preserve the requested effect set. If the original effects are mandatory, filter for those effects before comparing remainders; this unrestricted replacement table answers an expense-and-value question.
Two unavailable materials are not two independent penalties
Next we exclude each pair drawn from the four control ingredients. Each paired test has 1 + 14 + 14² + 14³ + 14⁴ = 41,371 eligible inputs. We rerank that complete constrained pool. The last column shows the sum of the two separate one-item losses only as a comparison; it is not used to predict the paired result.
| Excluded pair | Replacement additions | Value | Expense | Remainder | Actual loss | Sum of individual losses |
| Banana + Cuke | Mega Bean → Energy Drink → Chili → Battery | $187 | $28 | $159 | $12 | $13 |
| Banana + Horse Semen | Gasoline → Cuke → Battery → Mega Bean | $189 | $22 | $167 | $4 | $8 |
| Banana + Mega Bean | Paracetamol → Cuke → Motor Oil → Battery | $178 | $19 | $159 | $12 | $9 |
| Cuke + Horse Semen | Mega Bean → Energy Drink → Chili → Battery | $187 | $28 | $159 | $12 | $13 |
| Cuke + Mega Bean | Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine → Viagor | $185 | $23 | $162 | $9 | $14 |
| Horse Semen + Mega Bean | Paracetamol → Cuke → Motor Oil → Battery | $178 | $19 | $159 | $12 | $9 |
Excluding Banana alone loses $4 and excluding Horse Semen alone loses $4. Together, however, the optimized loss is still $4 rather than $8. Gasoline → Cuke → Battery → Mega Bean avoids both items, so the same replacement covers both constraints. Adding the separate losses would double-count the damage to this particular finite recipe choice.
The opposite happens with Banana and Mega Bean. Their individual losses sum to $4 + $5 = $9, but excluding both lowers the best remainder to $159, a $12 loss from $171. The joint loss exceeds that sum by $3. A material that was useful in one single-exclusion fallback may disappear under the second exclusion; the eligible sets must be intersected before ranking.
Cuke and Mega Bean provide another non-additive comparison. Their individual losses total $9 + $5 = $14, while the paired pool still allows Banana → Horse Semen → Iodine → Viagor, leaving $162. The actual loss is $9, not $14. These examples are exact differences in the recorded pools. They are not an estimate of how often a supplier runs out of stock.
Compare the extra expense with the lost remainder
The control spends $20. Without Cuke, the best available list spends $23 and has calculated value $185. It spends $3 more while returning $6 less value than the control, so the remainder loss is $3 + $6 = $9. Without Banana, the replacement spends $22 and has value $189: $2 more expense plus $2 less value gives the $4 loss.
For the Banana-plus-Mega-Bean exclusion, Paracetamol → Cuke → Motor Oil → Battery costs $19 and has value $178. Expense is $1 lower than the control, but value is $13 lower. The remainder loss is $13 − $1 = $12. Choosing only by the lower ingredient bill would conceal that difference.
To scale a unit comparison to an explicit hypothetical quantity q, multiply both the value difference and ingredient difference by q. At q = 20, the Cuke-exclusion replacement would require $60 more in additions and return $120 less calculated value, giving $180 less remainder. Twenty is a supplied example input here, not an observed batch or confirmed sale.
Questions before using a replacement
Does this mean those materials are unavailable in my game?
No. Exclusion is the experiment's input. We did not inspect your inventory, rank, store shelves, unlocks or supplier relationship. Choose the row matching your actual restriction; do not treat the table as an unlock guide.
Are the effects preserved when the remainder is close?
Not necessarily. The default table maximizes remaining calculated value and allows different final effects. The complete audit includes those effects. An effect-specific customer requirement is a different constraint, and customer acceptance was not measured.
Does the $171 include the base's production expense?
No. Subtract your measured production expense p and selling deduction d: net = calculated value − additions expense − p − d. If p and d are common to the compared same-base alternatives, they cancel in the difference. If an alternative changes either actual expense, enter that change rather than assuming cancellation.
What if I can use five or more additions?
The test ends at four. A longer sequence can change both the unconstrained winner and the exclusion fallback, so the displayed leader is not a global optimum over every length. Retest the expanded pool before carrying these rankings forward.
Reproduce the shortage test
- Choose Shrooms in the calculator, clear the previous mix and use the saved standard mode.
- Enter the complete ordered input for the control and compare its effects, $191 calculated value and $20 additions expense.
- Reset before entering a replacement. Never continue from the control's last state.
- Check the final effects as well as the two money columns; an equal remainder is not equal effect membership.
- Read the audit summary for the exact source hash and selection rules. The compressed complete input pool preserves every tested list.
The familiar four-addition control is a starting point, not a claim of a newly discovered recipe. The added information is the counterfactual: which replacement survives a stated exclusion, how much it recovers over deletion, and why paired exclusions cannot be priced by adding single-item losses. Keep the constraint with the recipe when you save it.
For cost-indexed recipes without an availability restriction, see the recipe collection. That page answers a budget question; this one changes the allowed ingredient set.