MIX / 01 · Calculator

METH MIXING CHECK · OCTOBER 10, 2026

Schedule 1 meth: when a second ingredient costs more than it adds

For Meth in this calculator, keep Cuke alone rather than adding Paracetamol if you want more value after ingredient costs. Cuke gives $85 sell value and $83 after its $2 ingredient cost. Adding Paracetamol raises sell value to $87 but raises ingredient cost to $5, leaving $82—$1 less per unit.

The decision here is whether one extra addition pays for itself. We executed the saved standard-mixing engine with all 16 single additions and all 256 ordered two-addition recipes. These are calculator results, not completed game sales. Production cost, accepted customer quotes and other expenses are not measured in this experiment.

Start with the single-addition checkpoint

Empty Meth returns a $70 sell value and no ingredient expense in this snapshot. The final column below compares each one-addition result with that $70 baseline. “After ingredients” means calculated sell value minus ingredient cost; it does not mean complete production profit.

AdditionIngredient costSell valueAfter ingredientsChange from empty
Cuke$2$85$83+13
Flu Medicine$5$88$83+13
Gasoline$5$70$65-5
Donut$3$90$87+17
Energy Drink$6$92$86+16
Mouth Wash$4$91$87+17
Motor Oil$6$94$88+18
Banana$2$84$82+12
Chili$7$97$90+20
Iodine$8$99$91+21
Paracetamol$3$87$84+14
Viagor$4$102$98+28
Horse Semen$9$106$97+27
Mega Bean$7$95$88+18
Addy$9$101$92+22
Battery$8$98$90+20

One useful comparison is Viagor against Horse Semen. The latter has the higher sell value: $106 versus $102. Its ingredient cost is also higher: $9 versus $4. Their after-ingredient values are therefore $97 and $98 respectively. A sell-value ranking reverses that pair’s economic order. This is a comparison of those two inputs, not a claim that a one-step recipe is best across every possible sequence.

Gasoline alone is another clear checkpoint. It costs $5 while sell value stays at $70, leaving $65 after ingredients, or $5 below the empty result. That does not prove Gasoline is useless in every longer recipe. It shows that an ingredient’s standalone contribution and its contribution after a particular prefix are separate questions.

Test the extra ingredient against the prefix you already have

Let S be rounded sell value and C be total ingredient cost. For a prefix A and an added ingredient B, the marginal after-ingredient change is [S(A,B) − S(A)] − [C(A,B) − C(A)]. Both terms come from executing the complete ordered recipes. Adding an effect does not guarantee that all previous effects remain unchanged.

A higher sell value can leave less after ingredientsMeth + Cuke: 85 − 2 = 83Then Paracetamol: 87 − 5 = 82Sell value rises by 2; extra cost is 3Saved-engine arithmetic, before production cost
Original marginal-value comparison from two saved-engine runs.

For Cuke then Paracetamol, sell value increases by $2 while cost increases by $3. The change is 2 − 3 = −1. At a hypothetical quantity of 20 identical units, that difference scales to −$20. Quantity is an arithmetic input here; it is not a record of 20 completed sales.

Ordered additionsPrefix → final sellExtra costSell changeAfter-cost change
Banana → Gasoline$84 → $70$5-14-19
Gasoline → Banana$70 → $84$2+14+12
Cuke → Paracetamol$85 → $87$3+2-1
Energy Drink → Mega Bean$92 → $95$7+3-4
Motor Oil → Mega Bean$94 → $95$7+1-6
Mega Bean → Iodine$95 → $99$8+4-4
Addy → Flu Medicine$101 → $102$5+1-4

The four other higher-price examples make the same distinction without using the same figures. Energy Drink then Mega Bean adds $3 of sell value but $7 of cost, so its change is −$4. Motor Oil then Mega Bean adds only $1 of sell value against $7 of cost: −$6. Mega Bean then Iodine adds $4 against $8: −$4. Addy then Flu Medicine adds $1 against $5: −$4. Every one finishes with a higher sell value than its prefix and a lower after-ingredient value.

Reversing the same two additions changes the stopping decision

Banana alone gives $84 sell value, $2 cost and $82 after ingredients. Gasoline added next changes the result to $70 sell value and $7 cost, leaving $63. The marginal change is (70 − 84) − (7 − 2) = −19. The final effects in the saved result are Smelly and Toxic.

Now reverse the order. Gasoline alone starts at $70 sell value and $5 cost, leaving $65. Banana added next produces $84 sell value and $7 total cost, leaving $77. That change is (84 − 70) − (7 − 5) = +12. The final effects are Smelly and Gingeritis. The same total ingredient expense of $7 does not erase the difference in the resulting effects.

The two finished recipes differ by $14 per unit after ingredients: 77 − 63 = 14. At quantity 20, the derived difference is $280. Yet the second-addition decisions differ even more sharply: one loses $19 against its own prefix while the other gains $12. Compare each finished recipe with its actual preceding state, rather than comparing everything only with an empty product.

What the exhaustive two-addition check does establish

There are 16 × 16 = 256 ordered pairs when repetition is allowed. We compared each pair with its matching one-addition prefix. In this exact grid, 213 second additions increased after-ingredient value, one was unchanged, and 42 reduced it. The counts sum to 256. They describe an enumerated set; they are not probabilities that a player’s next mix will succeed.

This grid ends after two additions and uses the saved standard rules. It does not include longer sequences, seeded mixing, ingredient availability, customer preferences or changes in a later game build. A negative second step can still be part of a useful longer sequence, but this experiment cannot supply that missing continuation. The immediate loss should remain visible instead of being labelled a gain because the final sell figure is higher.

Questions about this Meth comparison

Does entering the same base production cost change the marginal result?

If both compared recipes use the same base cost P per unit, subtraction cancels it: [S(A,B) − C(A,B) − P] − [S(A) − C(A) − P]. The result remains the sell-value change minus extra ingredient cost. If production expenses differ between the alternatives, their measured difference must also be included.

Can I use an ingredient’s default multiplier to predict the second step?

Not reliably for these examples. The ordered recipe may transform an existing effect. Banana then Gasoline and the reversed sequence have different final effect sets even though the ingredient list has the same two names. Execute the whole prefix and the whole candidate before subtracting their values.

What should be recorded before deciding to stop?

Record the ordered prefix, its sell value and total ingredient expense. Then record those same fields after the candidate addition. Keep the signed change beside the final value. A recipe with a larger displayed sell figure can still have a negative marginal contribution.

Keep the prefix beside the proposed addition

The result worth retaining is not a blanket instruction to stop after one ingredient. It is the signed comparison with the specific prefix: Cuke → Paracetamol loses $1 after ingredients, while Gasoline → Banana gains $12. Neither decision can be recovered from the final sell value alone.

The execution record saves the source SHA-256, empty result, all 16 single additions and all 256 pairs, including final effects and both marginal terms. The comparisons, counts and order-reversal arithmetic are independently derived from those runs.